Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

The Impact of Taxes on Same-Sex Marriage

The national debate over same-sex marriage reached a boiling point when the Supreme Court of the United States overturned a portion of the Defense of Marriage Act. The SCOTUS ruling gives legally-married same-sex couples the right to file a joint income tax return beginning in tax year 2013. It also grants same-sex married couples the right to amend prior year taxes that were already filed, so they may recoup overpayments.

As one might expect, collecting same-sex tax overpayments is challenging, as current forms are not written to easily accommodate the new rules.

Defining Legal Same-sex Marriage

The federal government defines a legal same-sex marriage as a same-sex, non-dependent couple who married in a jurisdiction after that jurisdiction recognized same-sex marriage. This means a couple who married in New York, New Jersey or Connecticut, for example, is eligible to file either a married filing jointly or married filing separately tax return.

Although federal rules permit legally-married same-sex couples the right to file a joint income tax return if they choose to live in a state that does not recognize same-sex marriage, the financial and personal risks can be severe. This is something to keep in mind for those who live in the tri-state area on a part-time basis.

Amending a Prior Year Return

Past tax law treated same-sex couples as strangers, and the new federal rules add up to significant savings for those who are legally married. For example, tax benefits enjoyed by married couples — such as spousal “death tax” avoidance, which can total hundreds of thousands of dollars and sometimes more — are now applicable to same-sex married couples in eligible prior years.

There are other financial benefits as well. A same-sex spouse who was once unable to take advantage of employer-sponsored health insurance and had to purchase private insurance can now join a family plan in states that recognize same-sex marriage.

Unfortunately, amending a prior year return to account for same-sex marriage using 1040X is complicated because the current format is not written with legal same-sex marriage in mind — making a costly mistake is easy.

The IRS has not yet issued instructions on how to modify two returns into one same-sex, married filing jointly, for prior year returns. Although the instructions on the existing 1040X form are relatively clear for a standard prior year adjustment, those who wish to make a change should contact an experienced CPA who will have the knowledge and expertise required to correctly amend an eligible prior year return.

Hiring a Professional

212 Tax offers a wide range of income tax services, including amending prior year returns to account for a legal same-sex marriage. For more information, contact us at (646) 699-4818 or .

Contact Us


1412 Broadway
21st Floor
New York, NY 10018

2916 N Miami Ave, 6th Floor
Miami, FL 33127

P: 646-933-9534
Request a Consultation We are able to work with your unique schedule including after-hour appointments, most weeknights, and weekends.
Press / Articles

blog talk radio

Please click above to hear Anil Melwani's radio appearances on Blog Talk Radio!
Email Updates

Enter your email address below to subscribe to our monthly newsletter.

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.